Coastal Contemporary vs. West Indies Style: What’s Defining Southwest Florida Architecture?

Coastal Contemporary vs. West Indies Style: What’s Defining Southwest Florida Architecture?

  • Earls Lappin Team
  • 06/10/25

In Southwest Florida, architecture tells a story of evolving tastes, coastal influences, and tropical elegance. Two dominant styles have emerged as favorites among homeowners, architects, and designers: Coastal Contemporary and West Indies. But what sets them apart—and which one is shaping the identity of Florida's Gulf Coast?

 

The Rise of Coastal Contemporary

Coastal Contemporary design blends clean lines with natural textures, creating a refined yet relaxed aesthetic. It reflects a modern, open-concept approach while embracing the light and airiness of coastal living.


Key Features:

  • Flat or low-pitched rooflines

  • Floor-to-ceiling windows

  • Seamless indoor-outdoor transitions

  • Neutral palettes with pops of blue or green

  • Minimalist landscaping with native flora

  • Materials like glass, stone, and weathered wood

This style appeals to those seeking a fresh, uncluttered environment that connects them with the outdoors—perfect for Southwest Florida’s year-round sunshine.

 

The Timeless Appeal of West Indies Style

West Indies architecture draws inspiration from Caribbean plantation homes, combining colonial elegance with tropical functionality. It’s designed for ventilation and shade, a natural fit for Florida’s subtropical climate.

Key Features:

  • Hipped roofs with deep overhangs

  • Shuttered windows and breezeways

  • Natural wood accents and textured exteriors

  • Lush landscaping with palms and tropical plants

  • Symmetrical façades and columned porches

  • Warm, earthy color palettes

This style exudes charm and hospitality, ideal for buyers looking for a classic coastal retreat with historical character.

 

Which Style Is Defining Southwest Florida?

Both styles are thriving in communities like Naples, Bonita Springs, and Marco Island. However, new construction trends lean slightly toward Coastal Contemporary due to its modern appeal and architectural efficiency. Still, many luxury homebuyers remain drawn to the timeless sophistication of West Indies design.

 

Final Thoughts

Whether you're building your dream home or scouting real estate in Southwest Florida, understanding these architectural styles can help you choose the right fit. Coastal Contemporary offers modern minimalism, while West Indies style embraces tradition and warmth. Both capture the essence of coastal living—just with different expressions.

WORK WITH US

Our track record of performance and masterful marketing endeavors produce results that customers seek. The result is a successful history of closed transactions and satisfied homeowners throughout the Naples luxury home community.

FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM